* Articles authored by Sandeep Pandey and Bobby Ramakant as appearing in the media:
http://mycitizennews.blogspot.com
* E-forum for development sector news from the South Asian region:
DailySouthAsian@yahoogroups.co.uk
(Subscribe by an email to: dailysouthasian-subscribe@yahoogroups.co.uk)
Corresponding Weblog: www.thesouthasian.org
* Replies to an ‘Open letter to Dr. Sandeep Pandey’ from an ‘Anonymous Former AID donor’
1. Dr. Pandey, who is sponsoring your present tour of the USA? How much expenditure does it incur? Don't you think that the money spent on this tour could have been better used to help poor people in India instead?
Ans: My present trip is sponsored by India Friends Association, Indians for Collective Action, individual donations from Asha volunteers, AID and grants from several Universities. Now what this money could have been best spent on is a debatable issue but what I can assure you is that my trip is taking place at the minimum possible expenditure. This trip is giving me an opportunity to explain our work to a lot of people, receive feedback and as a result generate further support for activities back home.
2. Dr. Pandey, you participated in a meeting honoring Naxalites who have murdered law enforcement officers and civilians.[2] CPI-ML, which organized the meet, has also announced in its publication that you attended the meet and called for revolutionary fronts like CPI-ML to unite.[3] You claim to be a Gandhian. Could you please explain how a Gandhian could support Naxalite terrorist organizations?
Ans: I support only the pro-poor stands of CPI-ML. Ideologically, I do not support violence and have never instigated violence anywhere. In the meeting that you refer to I had called for unity of Gandhian, Socialist and Left organizations to fight the communal forces. Now, CPI-ML is a political party which participates in parliamentary democracy in India and they even had 7 seats in the last dissolved Bihar assembly. If they are doing anything against the law, the law and order machinery in India will take care of it. In any case, the violence that you are accusing them of indulging in is not by their own choice. I have closely observed once as a journalist for Hindi daily ‘Nabharat Times’ in Ballia when mostly dalit members of the organization were at the receiving end of violence inflicted on them by powerful Yadav landlord army. I have also met their members in Siwan who have suffered lot of violence at the hands of goons of mafia don Member of Parliament Shahabuddin. Do you remember the young student leader, former President of JNU Students’ Union, Chandrashekhar, who was killed while making a speech at an important junction in the heart of Siwan city? Chandrashekahar was an AISA member, which is the student wing of CPI-ML. I work with CPL-ML because they work for poor and are even willing to risk their lives when fighting powerful vested interests. Some of them are very idealistic people.
3. Dr. Pandey, CPI-ML, whose conference you attended, calls for armed revolution and for raising an army.[4] Is it not hypocrisy to claim that you are a Gandhian but still attend CPI-ML conferences that call for armed revolution?[5] How does the violent and fundamentalist ideology of groups like CPI-ML fit into your self-professed Gandhian ideals? Do you wear one mask in front of American donors and volunteers and another in front of violent CPI-ML activists?
Ans: I do not support armed revolution. You’re just picking on one thing – my attending the CPI-ML meeting. You’re not telling your audience about my direct efforts which involve constructive cooperation with the government authorities in improving the situation for poor people in Hardoi through the right to information movement. Additionally, I attend meetings organized by a number of groups and political parties. I have also addressed a big meeting of Congress Party workers in Jan. 2005.
4. Dr. Pandey, many ASHA donors and volunteers live in America and some are even US citizens. You have called America "the biggest evil power on earth"[6] and "the biggest terrorist state."[7] If so, why do you and ASHA, which you founded, raise funds from the USA?
Ans: I distinguish between the policies of American Government of Imperialism and Militarism and the American people. Don’t you remember Gandhi was able to distinguish between the British as individual and their policies of domination of India. You’ll be surprised to know that an American citizen James Fassett Carmen walked along with us against Coca Cola from Ballia to Varanasi last year. The American government has killed more number of innocent people all over the world than any single organization. I have American friends who don’t have problems with me calling America as the biggest terrorist state.
5. Dr. Pandey, while you have no qualms about calling a democratic state like America terrorist, you have never used such words for real terrorists like the Al Qaeda and Taliban. In fact, you turned into an apologist for Al Qaeda in an interview you gave to a Muslim newspaper in the aftermath of the 9/11 massacre. Even though it had been proven that it was Al Qaeda terrorists who carried out the attacks you claimed that nobody knew who perpetrated the crime.[8] Could you please explain why you chose to whitewash a terrorist crime but didn't take side with American victims?
Ans: I do not support any terrorist organization, including Al Qaeda. What I have questioned is the US without providing proof of who was behind the 11/9/2001 incidents went and attacked Afghanistan, killing common citizens of Afghanistan, who obviously had noting to do with the attack in US. I condemn US Government as much as Al Qaeda and sympathize with victims of Afghanistan as much as victims of 11/9.
6. Dr. Pandey, in the same interview, you also expressed support for Kashmiri separatism. But you have never expressed your support for and sympathies with Kashmiri Pandits, who are victims of Islamic terrorism. The entire Kashmiri Pandit community of more than 700,000 was ethnically cleansed from Kashmir and nearly 400,000 of them languish in refugee camps. Why did you not ever support the victims but instead supported the oppressors?
Ans: I have again supported victims of violence in Kashmir and no oppressors. These victims could be Hindus or Muslims. What I have said is that the problem of Kashmir must be solved according to the wishes of people of J&K, Hindus and Muslims both. I have been informally approached by some Kashmiri Pandits and may attend any meeting to discuss their issue if invited.
7. Dr. Pandey, the newspaper mentioned above has sympathized with the Taliban.[9] Do you agree with their Taliban sympathies? If not, why would a person like you, who calls himself a Gandhian, disseminate his views through such media channels, implicitly giving them credibility?
Ans: These “conclusions” are not based on anything I have said or done. I do not support the Taliban and have not presented any articles to their media channels.
8. Dr. Pandey, recently you wrote an opinion editorial for Al
Jazeerah, where you demanded the release of an alleged Muslim criminal charged with abducting a woman.[10] Would you please explain why you opted to associate with a media outlet that has openly expressed anti-Semitic hatred and has been credibly accused of being connected to terrorist groups including Al Qaeda? Al Jazeerah has no circulation in India. Yet you chose it among several possible venues to publish your opinion on an issue concerning an alleged petty criminal from India. And perhaps even more surprisingly, Al Jazeerah published your piece. Which audience were you appealing to? What is your connection with Al Jazeerah?
Ans: I did not send any article to Al Jazeerah and would like to see the link of such an article. What you refer to is a letter that I had written to Home Secretary of U.P. Government to release my friend Moosa Azmi, which was posted on dailysouthasian@yahoogroups.co.uk.
He is not a Muslim criminal. He is part of the National Coalition for Dalit Human Rights and is dedicated to one of the most oppressed communities in our nation. He is a genuine social activist and a colleague who has been to jail with me in Varanasi in the anti-Coca Cola agitation in September 2003.
I am surprised that you can call somebody a criminal when you do not even know him. Fortunately, Moosa is out of jail after 33 days and the woman who you claim to have been abducted, who wanted to marry a Dalit man and stayed at Moosa’s place for two days after running away from her home, is now back with her parents.
9. Dr. Pandey, you have participated in several conferences and meetings organized by ASHA and AID in support of Muslim victims of the Gujarat riots. AID and ASHA have never organized any meeting, seminar, conference, or campaign in support of Hindu victims anywhere, but several other groups have organized such events in solidarity with victims of Islamic terrorism in Kashmir. Why have you never participated in or even expressed your support for such events? Do you think Hindu victims do not deserve sympathy? Would you urge ASHA and AID to make amends and sponsor events to express support for the Hindu victims of Islamic terrorism in Kashmir and Bangladesh?
Ans: Again you seem to be drawing your own conclusion. Asha has never been the lead organizer of any such meetings though members have participated. If you organize a meeting to support Hindu victims of Islamic terrorism in Kashmir and Bangladesh, I will attend it.
While we do not make any distinction between Hindu and Muslim groups, it would behoove you to look at the communities supported through Asha projects. (www.ashanet.org)
10. Dr. Pandey, as mentioned above, ASHA and AID have never sponsored an event in support of Hindu victims of terrorism and ethnic cleansing. But they have sponsored extremely sectarian events in association with groups such as the Indian Muslim Council USA (IMC-USA).[11] One of the key speakers in one such convention was Mohammad Ahmadullah Siddiqi who founded the banned Islamic terrorist organization, Student Islamic Movement of India (SIMI).[12] Would you be willing to publicly state that ASHA and AID should not associate with such organizations?
Ans: I do not have any role to play in the decision making of Asha and AID in US. Asha functions in a decentralized manner with local chapters free to take decisions about their involvement in any event. We do not work with any sectarian organization, Hindu or Muslim.
11. Dr. Pandey, would you be willing to ask ASHA and AID to co-sponsor events with Hindu organizations like the Ramakrishna Mission, Sathya Sai Organization, and ISKCON Bangalore which do exceptional charitable work all over India and serves poor people everywhere without regard to religion, caste, or language?
Ans: I’ll work with any organization doing constructive work for the betterment of humanity. Our only condition is that they should not be communal, i.e., they should not spread hatred against any other community. In Ayodhya I work with mostly Hindus, Sadhus and Saints, to ensure that the Ram temple issue is not used by organizations seeking political power by exploiting people’s religious sentiments and that the peace and harmony of Ayodhya is preserved. I have worked closely with people like Swami Agnivesh, and Acharya Satyendra Das, the chief priest of RamLalla Mandir, Ayodhya (the site of the proposed Ram Temple).
12. Dr. Pandey, last but not the least, do you unequivocally and without reservation denounce Communist and Islamic terrorism? Will you publicly denounce Communist and Islamic terrorist organizations?
Ans: I denounce terrorism. But I support the Communist Parties in India because they raise the issues of poor people and for them the issues are more important than merely political power. They certainly have more integrity than the right wing Hindutva groups who are merely interested in political power. The BJP went back on all its commitments, including that of ‘Swadeshi’ when it was in power.
13. Dr. Pandey, during the tsunami fund raiser, AID channeled funds through the Democratic youth Federation of India (DYFI), the youth wing of the Communist Party of India (Marxist), which has been implicated for fomenting violence.[13] The AID website also reported this. However, when the news became public, and people started to express reservation over AID's funding of communist outfits like DYFI, AID started removing the references to the diversion from its website.[14] Do you think what AID did was ethical? Would you publicly condemn AID for diverting charity funds to outfits that engage in violence?
Ans: DYFI is the youth wing of CPM, which is a party in power in West Bengal and has an important role to play in the running of the UPA Government. I personally have no problem in working with DYFI. Today on University campuses of India Left groups are the only idealistic groups who stick to any principles at all. Rest of the political groups resort to money and muscle power to maneuver their way in politics.